The Poudre School District (PSD) Board of Education is considering closing or consolidating our three historic mountain elementary campuses—Livermore, Red Feather Lakes, and Stove Prairie. While district leadership frames this as a necessary response to declining enrollment and budget constraints, the real-world impact on our children, families, and local economy tells a very different story.
Our three campuses function as a single, highly efficient school spread across a vast geographic region, sharing staff, specialized teachers, and administrative oversight to deliver some of the highest academic test scores in the district. Closing any of these campuses doesn’t just shuffle students down the street—it fundamentally disrupts rural life and puts our children at risk.
Hazardous Highway Exposure: Closing mountain campuses forces our youngest children onto US 287, a high-crash corridor that has seen 18 traffic fatalities since 2017 and 570 total crashes over five years.
Brutal Daily Schedules: Consolidated busing results in 10- to 12-hour door-to-door days for elementary students, requiring winter wake-up times as early as 4:35 a.m. and long waits at bus stops in freezing temperatures.
Impact on Health & Learning: Research shows long daily commutes lead to sleep deprivation, reduced classroom attentiveness, lower participation in activities, and increased chronic absenteeism.
The Financial Math Doesn’t Add Up
Taxpayer Surplus: Mountain homeowners pay $9.08 million annually in property taxes to PSD, while operating all three mountain campuses costs approximately $3.5 million. Mountain families generate $2.60 for every $1 their schools cost.
Minimal Savings, Forfeited Revenue: Closing these schools saves a mere 1.2% of PSD’s local property tax budget, before factoring in added busing costs and the loss of state “small attendance center” aid for remote schools.
Heavy Costs Pushed onto Families: Parents driving 40 miles one-way to town to avoid extreme bus rides face roughly $19,720 in annual mileage costs and 680 hours behind the wheel—the equivalent of 17 full work weeks per year.
Pushing Families Away From PSD
Forced daily commutes of 70+ miles round-trip make staying in PSD logistically impossible for working parents.
Pushing families toward charter schools, private schools, or homeschooling takes valuable state per-pupil funding directly out of the district while mountain property owners continue paying the full PSD tax levy.
We call on the Poudre School District Board of Education to uphold its commitment to equity, transparency, and rural taxpayers by taking the following concrete actions:
Immediately Remove Mountain Schools from the Consolidation Package
Exclude Rural Campuses: Formally vote to remove Livermore, Red Feather Lakes, and Stove Prairie Elementary from the final school consolidation and closure list.
Recognize Fiscal Disparity: Acknowledge that closing three schools costing ~$3.5M to operate yields a negligible gross savings (<0.9% of PSD’s budget), while mountain taxpayers contribute $9.08M annually in property taxes to PSD ($2.60 sent to the district for every $1 our schools cost).
Account for Student Flight: Factor in our community survey data showing 56% of mountain families will NOT enroll in town schools if local campuses close—a loss of 50+ students that will immediately wipe out $525,000 to $630,000+ per year in state per-pupil funding.
Grant a 3-Year Improvement & Value-Add Period
Establish Outdoor & STEM Magnet Programs: Transform mountain campuses into specialized regional hubs for forestry, agricultural STEM, and outdoor education.
Open Town-to-Mountain Choice Busing: Create a dedicated choice bus stop in town so Fort Collins and Laporte families can choice-in to mountain schools for specialized outdoor learning.
Pursue Institutional Partnerships & Grants: Partner with Colorado State University (CSU), Division of Wildlife (DOW), and US Forest Service to secure 21st Century Learning grants and outdoor education funding.
Capture Homeschool & Pre-K Students: Develop flexible hybrid options for local homeschool families and integrate uncounted AlphaBEST Pre-K students into official district enrollment planning.
Commission Accurate Door-to-Door & Safety Impact Studies
True Transit Time Metrics: Require transportation studies that measure actual door-to-door commute times from mountain homes (not just building-to-building metrics), accounting for the 20–30 minute drives parents already make to reach local stops.
Glade Reservoir Construction Impact: Require an independent engineering audit on the US 287 realignment for Glade Reservoir, assessing the impact of active blasting, heavy haul trucks, and 30+ minute construction delays on young children.
Early Development & Health Standard: Ensure student transportation plans adhere to pediatric health guidelines regarding morning REM sleep truncation, chronic fatigue, and cortisol elevation in elementary-aged children.
Honor Taxpayer Intent & Statutory Guarantees
Mill Levy Promises: Maintain the promise made in the voter-approved 2024 Debt-Free Mill Levy Override, which earmarked $4M annually for small school support and programming.
Rural Tax Equity: Ensure mountain taxpayers—who pay full rates into district facility levies—receive localized educational services rather than being forced to subsidize town infrastructure while receiving zero local facilities in return.
A BIG DISTRICT. THREE RURAL SCHOOLS. STRONGER TOGETHER.
Before taking a final vote, we urge the Board of Education to:
Massive Geography, Vested Responsibility
Poudre School District spans 1,856 square miles—a geographic footprint larger than the entire state of Rhode Island.
The Urban/Town Footprint: Fort Collins, Timnath, Wellington, and LaPorte cover just 74 square miles (1/25th of the district).
The Rural Footprint: The rural mountain area spans 1,782 square miles (24/25ths of the district).
Vast Coverage, Essential Access: These 1,782 rural square miles are served by just 3 elementary schools (Red Feather Lakes, Livermore, and Stove Prairie) out of PSD’s 31 total elementary schools. Red Feather Lakes Elementary sits farthest west, serving families up to 60 miles toward the Continental Divide.
By The Numbers: Exceptional Efficiency & Tax Equity
$12 Million Collected: Estimated annual mill levy revenue PSD collects directly from rural mountain taxpayers (excluding state per-pupil funding and additional revenue sources).
<$2 Million Operating Cost: The combined annual cost to operate all three rural mountain schools is less than $2 million—representing less than 0.5% of PSD’s total operating budget.
Proven Fiscal Efficiency ($2.34xvs. $1.8x): Rural school districts across Colorado are funded per-pupil at an average rate of 2.34 times the urban rate. However, Red Feather Lakes, Livermore, and Stove Prairie operate at only 1.8 times the rate—delivering a 0.54 efficiency savings to district taxpayers while remaining highly cost-effective.
Why These 3 Mountain Schools Matter
Essential Community Hubs: These schools provide vital access to essential Larimer County public services, including local financial support and mental health services.
Lifelines for Rural Working Families: Without localized elementary schools, long commutes make it nearly impossible for families to reasonably live, work, and raise children in the mountain corridor.
Protecting Property Values: Closing these schools devalues rural residential property and harms the long-term economic vitality of mountain towns.
Irreplaceable Community Assets: Two of the three mountain school properties carry deed reverter conditions and may revert back to original land owners if closed, causing the public to lose these historic community buildings entirely.
Community Survival: Schools keep rural communities alive. Red Feather Lakes, Livermore, and Stove Prairie are essential to the future and stability of Northern Colorado’s mountain towns.
Rural Schools. Stronger Communities. A Brighter Tomorrow.
INVEST IN ALL OF PSD | People • Places • Opportunity • A Stronger Larimer County
Take Action Today
Attend a Meeting
October 1, 5:30pm (School Family Info Session): Livermore Elementary School Cafeteria, 360 W County Road 74E, Livermore, CO 80536
October 6, 6pm (PSD Listening Session): Livermore Community Hall, 2044 W County Road 74E, Livermore, CO 80536
October 10, 1pm (Community Info Session): Livermore Community Hall, 2044 W County Road 74E, Livermore, CO 80536
October 12, 6:00-7:30pm (PSD Listening Session): Timnath Middle-High School (Auditorium), 4700 E Prospect Road, Timnath CO, 80524
October 14, 6:00-7:30pm (PSD Listening Session): Rocky Mountain High School (Media Center), 1300 W Swallow Road, Fort Collins, CO 80526
October 15, 6:00-7:30pm (PSD Listening Session): Poudre High School (Event Center), 201 N Impala Drive, Fort Collins, CO 80521
October 19, 6:00-7:30pm (PSD Listening Session): Fort Collins High School (Theater), 3400 Lambkin Way, Fort Collins, CO 80525
October 20, 4pm (Community Rally): 2407 Laporte Ave, Fort Collins, CO 80521